Skip to content

Following the closure of the NICE consultation on Hearing aids for adults with hearing loss: existing use assessment (HTG10886), the British Academy of Audiology (BAA) has formally written to NICE to express concerns about the process used to select expert contributors and the publication of commentary that included derogatory and unsubstantiated statements about regulated hearing healthcare professionals. Based on concerns identified during our review of the consultation documents, BAA felt it was important to seek clarification directly from NICE.

In the letter, BAA acknowledges the importance of robust debate and scrutiny within NICE’s assessment processes and recognises the need for a range of perspectives to be considered. However, we are concerned that comments published as expert evidence included broad generalisations about hearing aid dispensers, audiologists and non-governmental organisations, without supporting evidence. BAA believes that presenting such statements within an official assessment document risks undermining confidence in both NHS and independent hearing healthcare professionals.

The letter, signed by Dr Saima Rajasingam, President of the British Academy of Audiology, asks NICE to clarify the criteria used to assess the suitability of expert contributors, the safeguards in place to prevent prejudicial commentary from being presented as evidence, how factual inaccuracies are challenged or contextualised, and whether the language used in some submissions meets the standards expected of contributors to NICE processes.

BAA highlighted that hearing aid dispensers are regulated healthcare professionals registered with the HCPC and subject to professional standards, continuing professional development requirements and fitness-to-practise procedures. We believe it is essential that discussions about service delivery, workforce models and technology are informed by evidence and conducted in a manner that respects all regulated professional groups.

While some of the statements highlighted by BAA have since been removed by NICE from the current online version of the assessment, we remain concerned about the processes that allowed them to be published initially and the potential impact this may have on clinicians’ confidence in the recommendations and on public perceptions of hearing healthcare professionals.

BAA values its constructive relationship with NICE and the important role it plays in shaping healthcare policy and practice. We have requested a formal response and look forward to further dialogue on how expert contributions can be assessed and presented in a way that is fair, transparent and evidence-based.

Read the BAA letter to NICE here: BAA Letter to NICE

Back To Top